1. General information
2. Objectives of the intervention
3. NBS domains, ES and scale
4. Governance and financing
5. Evaluation and learning
Presence of an assessment, evaluation and/or monitoring process
No
Presence of indicators used in reporting
No
Presence of monitoring/evaluation reports
No
Availability of a web-based monitoring tool
No
Name of any specific impact assessment tools
Unknown.
Use of GIS in mapping impacts
No evidence in public records
Cost-benefit analysis
Unknown
Transparency
Community satisfaction
Description of locals satisfaction with the project
-"I may be slightly biased as Pinnacle Farms was my real introduction to what farming is and looks like here in AZ. I worked with Janna for just over a decade and am happy to be buying her produce nowadays!
Just the cutest property with amazing historic elements, adorable spaces to rent out for an overnight stay or event, and orchards to gawk at and harvest from in the right seasons." (14)
-'Cool little farm, tucked away off the main road. Fresh veggies and fruits and eggs, walk up and pay in the cash box, there's a camera for integrity. The owner has been there for years, help support his business by checking them out. There's also fresh honey and jarred goods as well." (14)
Just the cutest property with amazing historic elements, adorable spaces to rent out for an overnight stay or event, and orchards to gawk at and harvest from in the right seasons." (14)
-'Cool little farm, tucked away off the main road. Fresh veggies and fruits and eggs, walk up and pay in the cash box, there's a camera for integrity. The owner has been there for years, help support his business by checking them out. There's also fresh honey and jarred goods as well." (14)
Trade-offs & Negative impacts
Measures to prevent gentrification or displacement
Multiple impacts delivery (climate, biodiversity, just community)
No
Goal setting and impacts delivery
In the planning phase, the project aimed to address issues in all 3 key priority areas, but impacts were not delivered in all three key areas.
Reaching original project goals
Please specify the achievements of the project goals
Biodiversity:
1. Restoration of derelict areas: "The historic orchard property in Laveen came with a falling down 1918 adobe home, abandoned for many years prior. Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard." (1)
2. Increased number of species present: "Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard with over 1200 trees, including peaches and rare Maktoom Dates brought from Iraq in 1910 (which were one of the few living things left after the years of neglect.) In homage to Phoenix's agricultural past, I replanted the citrus orchard in the front of the property with lemons, grapefruits and oranges and mandarins." (1)
Restoration of heritage species: "The last few years, she’s enjoyed fulfilling a niche for ancient grains and will
continue to grow heritage varieties as the market evolves." (10).
Social justice and community:
1. Increased access to healthy/affordable food: "The 1200 tree orchard is nestled at the base of South Mountain and the self serve farm stand has a smattering of unique offerings during the season. Stop by and check it out especially during peach season!" (2)
2. Increased sustainability of agriculture practices: " Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, it became certified organic in 2015, and is slowly re-developing into a wonderful fruit orchard with many different varieties." (3)
3. Increased visibility and opportunity for marginalised groups or indigenous peoples: "Anderson owns 57 acres of farm land in total, and they all make up Pinnacle Farms. She is part of the growing number of women farmers in Arizona." (7)
4. Increased awareness of flora and fauna as culturally and historically meaningful: "Just last week, I harvested some beautiful rare Navajo Red Watermelons and it’s so gratifying to know you have participated in preserving the diversity of the food system by helping to provide the seed for people and discussion as to why it should be preserved." (11)
5. Protection of historic and cultural landscape / infrastructure: "The historic orchard property in Laveen came with a falling down 1918 adobe home, abandoned for many years prior. Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard." (1)
1. Restoration of derelict areas: "The historic orchard property in Laveen came with a falling down 1918 adobe home, abandoned for many years prior. Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard." (1)
2. Increased number of species present: "Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard with over 1200 trees, including peaches and rare Maktoom Dates brought from Iraq in 1910 (which were one of the few living things left after the years of neglect.) In homage to Phoenix's agricultural past, I replanted the citrus orchard in the front of the property with lemons, grapefruits and oranges and mandarins." (1)
Restoration of heritage species: "The last few years, she’s enjoyed fulfilling a niche for ancient grains and will
continue to grow heritage varieties as the market evolves." (10).
Social justice and community:
1. Increased access to healthy/affordable food: "The 1200 tree orchard is nestled at the base of South Mountain and the self serve farm stand has a smattering of unique offerings during the season. Stop by and check it out especially during peach season!" (2)
2. Increased sustainability of agriculture practices: " Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, it became certified organic in 2015, and is slowly re-developing into a wonderful fruit orchard with many different varieties." (3)
3. Increased visibility and opportunity for marginalised groups or indigenous peoples: "Anderson owns 57 acres of farm land in total, and they all make up Pinnacle Farms. She is part of the growing number of women farmers in Arizona." (7)
4. Increased awareness of flora and fauna as culturally and historically meaningful: "Just last week, I harvested some beautiful rare Navajo Red Watermelons and it’s so gratifying to know you have participated in preserving the diversity of the food system by helping to provide the seed for people and discussion as to why it should be preserved." (11)
5. Protection of historic and cultural landscape / infrastructure: "The historic orchard property in Laveen came with a falling down 1918 adobe home, abandoned for many years prior. Now known as Pinnacle Farms South, I purchased the property in 2011, and it is re-developed into a mixed fruit orchard." (1)
Long-term perspective
Yes
Cost-effective solutions
Unknown
Equitable impacts
Transformative capacity
Magnitude of change
Application of lessons learned
Perception of Environmental Change
Unknown
6. Sources
1.
Pinnacle Farms (n.d.). About Pinnacle Farms. [Source link] [Archive];
2.
Good Food Finder (n.d.). Phoenix Pinnacle Farms. [Source link] [Archive];
3.
CCOF (n.d.). Pinnacle Farms. [Source link] [Archive];
4.
Pinnacle Farms (n.d.). Meet the Farmette. [Source link] [Archive];
5.
FarmHer (2020). First Generation FarmHer Feeding Her Arizona Community. [Source link] [Archive];
6.
Malloy, C. (2019). Elegy for a Fruit-Treed Laveen Farm Near South Mountain. [Source link] [Archive];
7.
ZETINO, G. (2018). Arizona leads nation in proportion of female farmers. [Source link] [Archive];
8.
Davis, E (n.d.). 'A raging crisis': Metro Phoenix is losing its family farms and local food sources. [Source link] [Archive];
9.
Arizona Farm Bureau (2014). Meet Arizona Agriculture's Janna Anderson. [Source link] [Archive];
10.
Murphree, J. (2014). A Conversation with a Beginner Farmer: Janna Anderson. [Source link] [Archive];
11.
Natural Awakenings (n.d.). Phoenix Female Farmer: Turning Adversity to Opportunity: Janna Anderson started Pinnacle Farms when she purchased a Phoenix citrus orchard in 2011.. [Source link] [Archive];
12.
RFD TV (2020). FarmHer Janna Anderson Makes Her Mark in Phoenix. [Source link] [Archive];
13.
Jung, C. (2016). Women Move Up The Ranks Of Arizona's Agriculture Industry. [Source link] [Archive];
14.
(n.d.). Pinnacle Farm Reviews. [Source link] [Archive];
15.
Pinnacle Farms (n.d.). Events and Camping . [Source link] [Archive];
16.
Estes, C (2021). Phoenix Pledges Tree Equity For All Neighborhoods By 2030. [Source link] [Archive];
17.
Totiyapungprasert, P. (n.d.). They're reimagining the future of food in south Phoenix. Here's how you can be a part of it. [Source link] [Archive];
18.
Maricopa Association of Governments (n.d.). Arizona Demographics . [Source link] [Archive];
Comments
There is almost no information publicly regarding the governance and financing of the farm so most answers are unknown.
Public Images
Image
The orchard at Pinnacle Farms.
Pinnacle Farms.
Image
The Pinnacle Farms farmstand stands in Laveen
Chris Malloy
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by
Image
Pinnacle Farm South
https://www.facebook.com/phoenixpinnaclefarms/photos_by

